Birds of a feather, fly together

It's pleasing to have a flock of Siskins arrive in your garden, and thanks to ringing, we might know where they come from or go to, but can ringing tell us anything about the link between these individuals in the flock? A note in Bird Study by Juan Senar and Jeff and Allison Kew in 2015 revealed that the individuals in Siskin flocks have stable social bonds and move in stable social units.

Two more recent examples of Siskins apparently travelling together between Britain and both Finland and Sweden provide even more evidence to reinforce the existence of social bonding between migrating Siskins.

Hugh Insley writes:

The moment you take a ringed bird out of a net and realise that the number on the ring is not one of your own, is always pleasing. When the ring has a foreign inscription the pleasure rises to excitement.

Swedish ring being examined. Photo by Sandy Davidson

Following several spells of easterly winds this March, I wasn’t entirely surprised to find that one of the Siskins visiting my garden feeders (green pin on map below) was carrying a Swedish ring and had been ringed as a 5,M (last years fledgling, male) on 25 April 2017 at Overboda, Västerbotten (63 deg 51 min N 19 deg 55 min E) 1,490 km ENE of Inverness (red pin on map below).

Swedish Siskin recoveries are not as frequent as might be expected from such a close neighbour. Up to 2016 there had been 38 Swedish-ringed Siskins reported here, with 110 BTO-ringed individuals recovered there. This compares with 105 from, and 172 to, Norway. So, even though another bout of easterlies had followed, I was quite surprised to catch another Swedish ringed Siskin, on 4 April and even more so to get a third the following day. What was really interesting was that the third bird’s ring, was only seven numbers different from the bird caught the previous day so that it was nearly certain that these two birds had been ringed at the same location and were travelling together. Both birds had been ringed on 23 July 2017 at Handol, Jamtland (63 deg 16 min N 12 deg 26 min E) 1,119 km ENE of Inverness (blue pin on map below).



An email exchange with Malcolm Calvert of the South Manchester Ringing Group, with whom I swap quite a number of Siskins, revealed that he had had a similar experience over the weekend of 22/23 February 2016 when one of six Siskins caught in his North Cheshire garden was an adult and was carrying a Finnish ring; the bird had been ringed at Pori, Satakunta, Turku and Pori (purple pin on map below) on 15 May 2015. The following day Malcolm caught another six, and was delighted to learn that one of these had been recaptured two months later on 29 April 2016 at Niinivisi, Kupio  Finland (yellow pin on map below), albeit some distance from the ringing location of the Finnish ringed bird caught in his garden (brown pin on map below). Finnish recoveries are even scarcer than those from Sweden with only four Finnish-ringed birds reported here and 28 BTO-ringed ones reported in Finland up to 2016.

Two male Siskins squabbling over seed. Photo by Desmond Dugan

Any foreign recovery is interesting, but to find two different examples of pairs and probably groups, of Siskins apparently moving together is remarkable. It seems likely that Malcolm’s two Finnish recoveries involving his Cheshire garden would have involved birds that had been wintering in Britain. The Swedish birds in my Inverness garden could also have been birds that had wintered in Britain, returning north with all the other Siskins which seem to move up into the Highlands in March and April. Many of these travel via the Manchester area, as evidenced by all the exchanges with the South Manchester Ringing Group, or perhaps they might have been the result of drift migration following all those easterly winds?


Siskins at a feeder. Photo by Desmond Dugan

Siskin was the sixth most-ringed bird in 2017 with in excess of 35,000 individuals ringed. Even so, or perhaps because of this effort, every year is bringing new knowledge to our understanding of these charismatic little garden visitors.

Exceptional Siskin Surge

The Siskin movement this autumn has been exceptional, for both the early start and vast numbers involved, as indicated by BirdTrack. With the peak movement and arrival of continental birds still to come, numbers in the UK are expected to increase considerably.


BirdTrack Siskin reporting rate

Jeff Kew from Thetford, Norfolk writes:

This has been an exceptional September for Siskins in the UK, with large numbers being reported across southern Britain, due to a major irruption from Northern Britain.

Last autumn Siskins were fairly scare in Southern England with a few being reported on feeders in February and March, the usual peak time to see and ring this species. Reports from Scotland indicate a bumper cone crop last summer and consequently most Siskins stayed at home for the winter, this Autumn with dwindling food supplies the picture is very different.

In the Norfolk / Suffolk Brecks area we have not seen anything like the numbers coming to feeding stations in September since 2005.

In our Thetford garden we have already ringed 611 Siskins this month (in just 4 ringing sessions), with an amazing 368 caught on the 18 September.

One of the hundreds of Siskins recorded taken by Jeff Kew

We have had birds ranging from exceptionally light (10.4g) to exceptionally heavy (17.0g) - which presumably indicates a mix of recently arrived birds and birds with serious intent to travel much further south. The majority are juveniles, which appear to have done less post juvenile moult than our local breeders.

Post juvenile moult strategies are interesting with the amount of post juvenile moult being variable and probably linked to both fledging date and food supply. We believe unmoulted juveniles (3JJ) can reach us from Scotland.

Thinking back to what we saw in 2005 we had high numbers through September, followed by two recoveries in Spain in Navarra and on Mallorca - which could give an indication of where some birds of this years birds may end up this winter.

Greg Conway from Thetford Forest Ringing Group writes:

The extent of post juvenile moult is highly variable, with some typically retaining one, or more, old greater coverts along with juvenile tertials and tail feathers, whereas others replace all coverts, tertials and tail (see below).  However, there are also many in between that replace different numbers of tertials and tail, often symmetrically but not always centrally!

Juvenile Siskin with replaced greater coverts, tail and tertials - Greg Conway

Juvenile Siskin with replaced greater coverts and two inner tertials - Greg Conway

Juvenile Siskin that has replaced outer pair and 2 central pairs of tail feathers contrasting with juvenile feathers (pointed and browner) - Greg Conway

To better understand the mix of different migration and post juvenile moult strategies occurring this autumn, and add to long-term data collected from Thetford Forest, ​any ringers catching Siskins are encouraged to record the following biometrics (in addition to age/sex, wing & weight):

All birds if possible!
1) Number of unmoulted greater coverts (including those with zero)
2) Fat score (0-8 scale)​

And if time allows!
3) Tertial moult (record in IPMR moult card)
4) Tail moult (record in IPMR moult card)
5) Pectoral muscle score (0-3 scale)

Spring Siskins in Russia

March is always a good time to be out catching Siskins, as this is the time they are on the move. Many of these birds will be 'local' breeders from northern England or Scotland, but some do come from much further afield.

Just today we received details of two BTO-ringed birds recaught by Russian ringers at the Rybachiy Ringing Station. X168805 was originally ringed in Northamptonshire on 30 March 2008 and found just 17 days later, whilst X036370 was ringed in Norfolk on 26 March 2008 and recaught on its way back to us on 14 October 2008.

We only have records of 21 other Siskin movements to Russia, nine of which were to Rybachiy, so these two together are exceptional.


View Larger Map